Community reacts to sentencing of Oxford High School shooter's parents

Posted at 11:52 PM, Apr 09, 2024

PONTIAC, Mich. (WXYZ) — It was the culmination of a historic, precedent-setting case with both parents of the Oxford High School shooter getting 10 years to 15 years behind bars.

From the verdict to sentencing, many in metro Detroit and across the country have had eyes on this historic trial, which on Tuesday included impact statements from the families of the four students killed and others injured.

Video below: Sentencing of James and Jennifer Crumbley and impact statements

James and Jennifer Crumbley sentenced to 10-15 years in Oxford case

“I can feel their pain and I know they probably wish they got life,” Martez Durant said.

Despite 10 years to 15 years being the maximum sentence, some who followed the case felt the parents should’ve gotten more.

“To me, it's unfair for some kids to lose their life and the parents get 10 to 15 years,” Durant said. "You can't replace a life, but I think the punishment should be more."

The shooter opened fire at Oxford High School on Nov. 30, 2021, killing four students – Tate Myre, Hana St. Juliana, Madisyn Baldwin and Justin Shilling – and injuring six other students and a teacher.

Updated photos: Oxford victims
Oxford victims

“We really need to be mindful and pay more attention to our children's actions and their behavior," Paquana Jones said. "The kid to me was crying out and reaching out with the drawings and such.”

Everyone who agreed to speak with 7 Action News on camera felt a maximum sentence for both parents was fair.

“I think the sentence is just," Chris Gopigian said. "I think parents need to be responsible for their kids and their actions, and kids need to be responsible for themselves.”

“Your heart goes out to the people hurt by this and the children that lost their lives and that's obviously the first that comes to mind... At the end of the day are they (parents of shooter) victims? No, I don't think so. Does my heart go out to them? Yeah," Josh McKenna said of the shooter's parents. "They've been affected by this drastically. Their lives have been forever changed, they're losing their son forever, so there's a certain level of sympathy attached to that.”

Hear from Oakland County Prosecutor Karen McDonald following the sentencing in the video player below:

Karen McDonald speaks to the media after James and Jennifer Crumbley's sentencing

While the vast majority of comments on our Facebook page also agreed with the sentence, some didn't like one person who called the sentence a slippery slope and another who said the judge went too far.

"Some people may look at it as being unfair, but it's just justice," Jones said. "You have to look at it, what if it was your child?”

“Justice was probably served and it's probably not the justice that the people want," McKenna said. "But I think it's closing a chapter on a very, very dark story for our area.”

Related: James and Jennifer Crumbley sentenced to 10-15 years in Oxford High School shooting